Broken links and 404 pages: how to check your site

A broken link sends a visitor to a page that no longer exists. The ones in your menu and footer matter most, because every visitor can reach them. Check that each link ends on a working page, that a missing address returns a real 404 status, and that the error page leads back into your site.

Check my links and 404 page

By the Neue World growth team · Updated November 2026

Summary

  • Menu and footer links come first: every visitor can reach them.
  • A missing address should return a real 404 status, not the homepage and not a normal page.
  • Point links straight at their final address. A chain of redirects adds delay.
  • Give the 404 page a way back: a link to the homepage and the main sections.

What is website navigation?

Navigation is how visitors move around your site: the menu, the footer, and the links between pages. Structure is what sits underneath: the address of each page, the redirects when a page moves, and what happens when someone opens an address that doesn't exist.

When it works, nobody notices. When it breaks, a visitor clicks your menu and lands on an error page, and search engines lose track of which pages are real.

Why it matters

Visitors

They hit a dead end

People use your menu to find what they need. A broken link leaves them on an error page with nothing to do next.

Google

Broken pages leave search

Google takes pages that return an error out of search. It is also confused by an error page that looks like a normal page, which it calls a soft 404.

AI search

AI sees less of you

ChatGPT, Claude and Perplexity read websites with their own crawlers to find pages for their answers. A page they can't reach, they can't use, so a broken link hides part of your business from them.

Your team

A quick fix

Most broken links point to old pages that were renamed or removed. Once you know where they are, they're quick to fix.

What good looks like

These are the practices behind the checks, in plain words.

Menu and footer links that all work

Every link in the header, menu and footer opens a working page. (Tools call this a broken link checker.)

A custom 404 page that returns a real 404

A page for addresses that don't exist, in your own design, that also tells browsers and search engines the page is not found. The status matters as much as the words on the page.

No redirect chains

A redirect sends a visitor from an old address to a new one. A chain is a link that passes through several redirects before it lands. Point the link straight at the final address.

A way back from the error page

The 404 page links to the homepage and the main sections, so a visitor who hits a dead link can carry on.

Links inside your page content, and links from other sitesNot in our analysis

Old articles link to pages that moved, and other sites link to addresses you removed. Worth reviewing, but the analysis does not test them.

How to check your own site

You can check all of this by hand in about ten minutes.

  1. Click every menu and footer link

    Open your site and click every link in the menu and the footer. Note any that show an error or land somewhere you didn't expect.

  2. Open an address that doesn't exist

    Type a made-up address after your domain, such as yoursite.com/this-page-does-not-exist. You should see your error page.

  3. Check that it says 404

    In your browser's developer tools, open the Network tab and reload: the first request should show 404. In Google Search Console, the Page indexing report lists pages Google sees as "Not found (404)" or "Soft 404".

  4. Look for a way back

    On the error page, look for a link back to the homepage.

Or run the free analysis, which checks these for you. Check my links and 404 page

Common mistakes, and how to fix them

MistakeWhat it costs youHow to fix it
Menu or footer links lead to missing pagesThis usually happens after a page is renamed or removed and the menu is not updated. Visitors who use your menu land on missing pages. Fix or remove the broken links.
Some menu links go through redirect chainsA link that points at an old address and relies on a redirect to reach the new one. Pages load slower through extra redirects. Point these links straight at their final address.
Unknown addresses don't return a real 404 pageCommon when the site sends every unknown address to the homepage, or shows a normal page. The page looks fine to a visitor, but the status says it exists. Search engines can treat error pages as real pages. Return a proper 404 page for addresses that don't exist.
The 404 page gives visitors no way backThe error page is a bare message with no menu or link. Visitors who hit a dead link have nowhere to go. Add a link to the homepage and main sections on the 404 page.

What our analysis checks

We check menu, header and footer links, up to 80 across the pages we read. We don't crawl every link in your content, and we don't check links from other sites. Code decides each of these, so the same pages always get the same result.

Pass

A made-up address on fieldnote.example returns HTTP 404, not a normal page or a redirect to the home page.

Needs fixingUnknown addresses don’t return a real 404 page

Return a proper 404 page for addresses that don’t exist.

Unknown addresses return a proper 404

We open a made-up address. It should say "not found" (404 or 410), not send visitors to the homepage or show a normal page.

Pass

The 404 page links back to the home page (2 links to the site in total).

Needs fixingThe 404 page gives visitors no way back

Add a link to the homepage and main sections on the 404 page.

The 404 page links back to the site

We read your 404 page for a link back to the homepage, so a visitor who hits a dead link can carry on.

FAQ

Questions people ask

01What is a soft 404?

A page that tells visitors it doesn't exist but returns a 200 "success" status. Google's documentation describes it this way. For a page you removed with no replacement, it recommends returning a 404 or 410; for a page that moved, a 301 redirect.

02Should my 404 page redirect to the homepage?

No. Redirecting every missing address to the homepage hides the error, and our analysis fails it. For a removed page with no replacement, Google's guidance is to return a 404 or 410.

03How many links does the analysis check?

Up to 80 menu, header and footer links across the pages we read. It does not check every link in your content, or links from other sites.

04What does "not verified" mean?

Some sites block or rate-limit automated visits. When we can't open a link we report it as not verified, never as broken. It costs a quarter of that check's points and is never counted as a failure.

Find the broken links in your menu.

The free analysis opens every menu and footer link, tests your 404 page, and names the pages to fix. It checks the rest of your site too. Free, no account.

We send the report link here. No newsletter.

Takes 2 to 4 minutes. Keep this page open, or save its address to come back. A site analysed in the last 7 days returns the saved report straight away.